top of page
HONEST TO GOODNESS JERSEY BAGELS, ROLLED , BOILED & BAKED DAILY SINCE 2014
AS OF JANUARY 10, 2021 WE WILL NO LONGER BE ACCEPTING TEXT ORDERS. TO PLACE AN ORDER, PLEASE CALL THE SHOP AT (732) 414-2330.
We are in no way associated with LOTR, Tolkien, or any other subsidiaries & affiliations within the Hobbit properties. Our owner is just a very, very big fan of the franchise...so this is our look now. Please don't sue us.
“A hungry man sometimes wearies of distrust and longs for bagels.”— Aragorn
Each day we arrive at 4am to start making our bagels from scratch. Our oven is a classic bagel making workhorse and our meticulously hand-rolled bagels are unmatched by any in the area...but that might be why so many people join us every single morning for their fix of deliciousness.
Next time you stop in, find Chris aka "Bagel Jesus" and if you throw a quote from LOTR his way, you'll get 10% off your order if he doesn't respond back with one right away.
No, we're not kidding.
One does not simply "like" bagels.
FOLLOW US ON INSTAGRAM: @TheBagelStoreNJ
Up early and rolling daily.
WANT TO GET REMINDERS & EARLY ACCESS TO NEW MERCH, AS WELL AS STORE SPECIALS? JUST PUT YOUR EMAIL HERE AND YOU'RE SET. NO SPAM. EVER!
bottom of page